What people are saying

  • 5 stars! I ordered custom cookies for my boyfriend’s golden birthday and Caitlin knocked it out of the park! She was so open to all my ideas and worked extra hard to get the cookies exactly like my vision. Not only was she extremely accommodating and the cookies looked amazing, but they taste delicious too! The frosting doesn’t overpower the sugar cookie and it’s just the perfect sweet treat. I will absolutely be going back to her for other special occasions in the future!

    - Bridget Van Steelant

  • "I recently ordered a heart-shaped vanilla cake from Collie Collective for my daughter’s first birthday, and it was amazing! The cake was beautifully decorated, super fluffy and delicious. The vanilla flavor was just right—not too sweet, but very tasty. Everyone at the party loved it. My husband even said “I’m not a cake person, but this may be the best cake I have ever had.” The next day he was eating it straight out of the box with a fork for breakfast. Caitlin was amazing to work with and really did a fantastic job. I highly recommend Collie Collective!"

    — E. Wiles

  • “You will not be disappointed when ordering from Collie Collective Bakery! My brother and sister-in-law purchased some adorable cookies to celebrate our baby girl that’s on the way. The extreme details that was crafted onto each cookie was so impressive! Not only was the art work impressive the taste of the cookies was to die for! I have had plenty of sugar cookies previously from other bakeries, these ones take the cake! I promise you will not be disappointed!!".”

    — Sabrina Roberts

  • "Caitlin, I just wanted to thank you personally for the wonderful cake you created for our Granddaughters 1st birthday. I was so impressed and so was everyone else!!! Your attention to detail is incredible and very much appreciated. It seemed such a shame to have to cut into it, but I’m glad we did because the cake itself was delicious and light with a delicate and creamy icing, just perfect. I made sure to sneak some leftovers for the next day's dessert! Your creativity and artistry really made Sadie's cake special and I would certainly recommend you to all of my friends without hesitation. Rest assured that we will definitely be using your bakery to plan future family celebrations."

    — S. Hull

  • "Caitlin is hands down the best baker I've ever tried. I used to be a Crumbl fan until I had her cookies. Her cakes are fantastic as well. We had a cinnamon sugar cake for a friend's birthday and it was gone so quick! I will be getting all my sweet fixes from her from now on!

    - Jerod W.